spinofflive
Wind turbines on the outskirts of Canberra. (Photos: SAEED KHAN/AFP/Getty Images).
Wind turbines on the outskirts of Canberra. (Photos: SAEED KHAN/AFP/Getty Images).

The BulletinApril 17, 2018

Strange but true: Australia has a lot to teach us about renewable energy

Guest writer
Wind turbines on the outskirts of Canberra. (Photos: SAEED KHAN/AFP/Getty Images).
Wind turbines on the outskirts of Canberra. (Photos: SAEED KHAN/AFP/Getty Images).

With the announcement that the Government will end offshore oil and gas exploration in New Zealand, and at the end of our four-yearly schooling by Australia in how to win medals, Vector’s Karl Check says parts of Australia are also making pretty good progress when it comes to shifting away from coal and gas fired power plants and onto renewal energy sources.

We love our Australian cousins but it’s been hard to resist a few good natured chuckles as we bore witness to such recent misfortunes as imploding politicians, ball-abusing sportsmen and a batting collapse that rivals, well, our own. Yes, reciprocal schadenfreude is one of the bonds that binds our two countries but when it comes to renewable energy we’re way ahead of those coal-burning Aussies, right?

Well, yes and no.

While there’s still lots of coal being burnt in Australia, the Australian Capital Territory (ACT) is going for 100% renewable energy by 2020. That’s from a starting point of about 80% non-renewable energy back in 2014-15. And they’re on track to get there, in just six years.

As for New Zealand, it’s not that we’re doing badly. Most of our electricity is already pretty clean. Our lakes and geothermal plants give us around 80%, even if the geothermal ones do emit greenhouse gases, yet still coal and gas are picking up the slack.

Yet, it feels like we’re still in the phase of talking about making the switch to 100% renewable electricity generation by 2035. As far as the relationship between Aussies and Kiwis goes, that’s not the right way around.

The Australian Capital Territory (ACT, or Canberra and some extra bits of bush) might have a population around the size of Greater Wellington but they’re punching well above their weight for using new technology and innovative ways of thinking to get to where they are. What they’ve been up to makes for a great case study for somewhere like Auckland, with a similar concentration of urban population with outlying rural areas:

  • Hydrogen powered cars. They’re touted by some as a better alternative to electric cars because, while they have zero tailpipe emissions, they also have a range of around 600kms. That puts them right on par with the cars you, and your mum and dad, have driven for years.
  • Grants to fund the rollout of residential solar and battery systems to 5000 homes, a number that’s getting up to the point where it becomes its own virtual power plant. This idea isn’t new; Vector and Entrust arranged the installation of 130 similar systems in Auckland, but the numbers were that much higher because the state got involved.
  • Reverse auctions that use the financial clout of the state to drive private sector investment in building 600MW of wind generating capacity (two thirds the capacity of New Zealand wind generation), while also compelling successful bidders to work with and invest in the communities they serve.
  • A community solar scheme that guaranteed a solar buyback rate of 20 cents per kilowatt hour, two and a half times what we get here.

So how did they get all of this off the ground in such a short space of time? One of the key players in making it happen was Simon Corbell, who’s currently providing independent advice to the public and private sectors on renewable energy (and who also holds the official title of Victorian Renewable Energy Advocate).

I met Simon a few weeks ago on a whirlwind tour of New Zealand, arranged by Vector, to pick his brains about how we can get the last 15-20% renewable energy we need to hit the magic 100% renewable energy target. He’s a nice guy. Very smiley. Describes himself as a “recovering politician” (he’s the former Climate and Energy Minister for ACT, as well as former ACT Deputy Chief Minister). He’s very passionate.

Simon’s pretty clear on what needs to happen to get cities like Canberra, Melbourne, Auckland, Wellington… (pretty much any city, really) to lower their carbon emissions. Start with electricity (see above), then look at transport and other sectors. Technology buys us time to work on the deeper societal shifts that might be required to wean ourselves off what we currently think of as normal (like switching from angrily tooting at the motorist hogging the petrol pump to taking a break for 15 minutes while your EV charges).

In Simon’s view, the opportunity is right there for the Australian Capital Territory to jump ahead even further.

With their electricity generation piece already sorted, next up is electrification of the transport sector. Once EVs are out there, work out how to integrate all those mobile batteries with the electricity network so they can help spread the load at peak times. Electric buses, with their large batteries, would be great for this: when they’re not being used to move people around they can be used to move electricity around instead. Once the evening commute is over those big batteries can be plugged into the network in time for people to cook their dinner, watch Netflix and collapse into bed, tired, warm and fuzzy from saving all those carbon emissions. It’s worth thinking about this in the context of the recent government announcements on transport priorities, which have signalled a shift in priorities away from roading infrastructure to alternative transport options.

By now it was clear to me that Simon’s enthusiasm, and the ACT’s success in going renewable, isn’t just confined to one part of Australia. He pointed out that not only was South Australia one half of a bizarre, yet thoroughly modern Twitter deal with Elon Musk, it’s also just approved 150MW solar energy delivered in the form of an only-slightly-ominous concentrated solar tower (it looks like Saruman’s tower from the Lord of the Rings but instead of a disembodied evil eye it has mirrors to focus the solar energy at a collector at the top).

PS10 Solar Power Plant, Planta Solar 10, is the A concentrating solar power tower operating in Sanlucar la Mayor near Seville, Spain (Photo by: Bildagentur-online/UIG via Getty Images).

So we’ve got some catching up to do with some parts of Australia. But the good thing is, in a way, we have even more to gain.

While New Zealand’s hydro resources are the envy of many an overseas country trying to wean itself off coal or nuclear, we’re at the mercy of the weather to keep those lakes filled up with water. Not enough water means not enough generating capacity, which in turn leads to massive rises in spot prices for wholesale electricity.

In the industry, this is known as “dry year risk”. Simply put, it’s the risk that over the year we won’t get enough rain to fill the lakes, or enough snow to melt and flow through to the lakes later on. We only have about eight weeks of power stored in our lakes while Norway, another leader in hydro electricity, has two years. Still, our electricity system includes multiple generation sources and can cope reasonably well with the odd dry year, but what happens if we get a couple in a row? Right now in New Zealand the gap between having enough water and not enough water is filled by things like old-fashioned coal-fired electricity generation, which runs a little against our national aspirations for a low-carbon future.

In Simon’s view this can be can be addressed by encouraging more localised generation and storage such as solar and batteries, because it gives us more options. In parts of Australia, for example, there has been exponential growth of solar, with consumers and businesses seeing it as a way to take control of their electricity bill. While Australia has a different environment, there is no reason this principle couldn’t work here too, and deliver the added benefit of taking some of the pressure off hydro. And like the bus example, if you can work out how to link up all the batteries out there then you’ve got another way of shifting electricity around to where it’s needed, buying a bit more time for the rain to come.

More Reading

    There are naysayers out there who’ll tell you that residential solar and batteries will never get you past a massive hydro shortage, and to a certain extent they’re right. You’d need about 1.1 million residential systems to replace Manapouri, but every bit of localised generation and storage would certainly help.

    But if we need to go next-level, then how about a partnership with X, Google’s moonshot factory? They’re working on a plan to store energy in giant salt tanks. Could be a good opportunity to get one over those Aussies. 

    This content is brought to you by Vector. If you live in Auckland, they also delivered the power you’re using to read it. And they’re creating a new energy future for all of us, as showcased by the incredible Vector Lights.

    Keep going!
    Simon Bridges and Jacinda Ardern (Image: Radio NZ).
    Simon Bridges and Jacinda Ardern (Image: Radio NZ).

    The BulletinApril 17, 2018

    The Bulletin: Poll – Labour lower, National no mates

    Staff Writer
    Simon Bridges and Jacinda Ardern (Image: Radio NZ).
    Simon Bridges and Jacinda Ardern (Image: Radio NZ).

    Good morning, and welcome to The Bulletin. In today’s edition: A new poll is out, the government is considering public-private partnerships, and rents are rising rapidly.

    A new 1 News Colmar Brunton poll shows a drop for Labour, but government parties still comfortably ahead of the National party. It’s being reported by 1 News as the ‘end of the honeymoon’ for Jacinda Ardern, but opposition leader Simon Bridges is also struggling to gain personal traction. If an election were held today, National would have no viable support partners.

    It should be noted that it’s only the second 1 News Colmar Brunton poll of the year, and as such it’s pretty difficult to draw conclusions out of it. The polling was conducted between the 7th and 11th of April, which was on the tail end of the government’s major changes to transport policy, or a more generalised perception of a government constantly fire-fighting. But it could also just be statistical noise. The election is two and a half years away.

    One area of interest out of the poll is that voters in general are less optimistic about the economy than when National were in power this time last year. Again, drawing big conclusions from one figure is difficult, but it could be that voters have been taking heed of warnings about a stingy budget in May. Or, it could be a similar state of affairs to business confidence surveys, which an analysis from Stuff showed were largely more optimistic under National governments, regardless of actual economic conditions.

    The government is considering using public-private partnerships to fund the building of infrastructure, reports the NBR (paywalled) Political reporter Brent Edwards notes that while the government opposes such deals in health, education and corrections, they’re open to it to build roads, public transport projects, and water infrastructure. Interest reports transport minister Phil Twyford is especially keen on private sector cash, particularly for projects like Auckland’s light rail.

    Rents are up again, and this time jumping more in a quarter than the whole increase between March 2016 to March 2017, reports Stuff. Property investors say it’s because the cost crunch is coming on landlords because of tighter regulation, but economist Shamubeel Eaqub says other factors, like high demand for rentals, are more credible.

    Good news for trades and services suppliers for Fonterra, as the dairy giant is abandoning a delayed payment policy, reports the NZ Herald. The policy, described as a PR disaster, was wildly unpopular in farming towns like Morrinsville, because through a payment chain effect it put pressure on everyone in the community. It’s not just Fonterra who have used this practice either – check out Rebecca Stevenson’s reporting for The Spinoff on which of our large corporates pay their bills late.

    New Zealand has picked up support from France for trade negotiations with the European Union to go ahead, reports Radio NZ. In the NZ Herald, Claire Trevett reports that the PM’s visit to Europe is partly an exercise in building relationships with EU nations, now that our closest ally in the group Britain is leaving. Ardern will meet German chancellor Angela Merkel tonight, and then head to London for a Commonwealth meeting.

    There’s some cracking front-page stories around the country today. The NZ Herald is leading with a story about angry dads protesting outside the homes of Family Court judges. In Christchurch, the Press reports councillors want Fletchers to be stripped of an $800 million project, which has been plagued by endless delays. And in Wellington, the Dominion Post reports taxpayers are being asked for $25 million from central government for Peter Jackson’s movie museum, to meet ballooning costs.*

    *An earlier version of this post incorrectly said Peter Jackson was asking for the $25 million. It was in fact a request from the Wellington City Council. 

    With the Commonwealth Games completed, and New Zealand returning home with a huge haul of medals, the question is being asked: Will New Zealand one day soon host another Commonwealth Games? No, says PM Jacinda Ardern. That’s probably the end of the matter for another four years.

    Sign up to The Bulletin





    Beyonce at Coachella Valley Music And Arts Festival (Photo: Larry Busacca/Getty Images)

    Right now on The Spinoff: Economist Eric Crampton describes New Zealand’s foreign house buyer ban as ‘lunacy.’ Guest writer Jogai Bhatt writes the definitive reaction to Beyonce’s awe inspiring Coachella set. And fair warning, this piece may make you cringe – father Adam Mamo explains dad jokes.

    Cabinet’s decision on whether to build the so-called ‘mega prison’ – a new $1 billion, 3000 bed facility at Waikeria – will be coming soon. The prison population is increasing (though crime rates are dropping) and Corrections basically needs more space.

    There will be lots of pieces written both for and against the mega prison, and about our prison system generally, when the decision is made. In the mean time, this e-Tangata interview with lawyer Julia Whaipooti, about Māori imprisonment and the ‘Māorification’ of prisons, is an absolute must read. It’s a crucial insight when around half the current prison population is Māori. Here’s a sample:

    “I’d been to Rimutaka a number of times in my capacity as a lawyer. And I remember this time how it hurt, how it broke my heart, going to the Māori focus unit and having the karanga come from within that unit, and having a pōwhiri from the Māori inmates, as tangata whenua, welcoming us in.

    So, it was me, Crown lawyers and judges, being welcomed into the prison by this group — as if they belonged there and as if we were manuhiri visiting. And I felt that Māori do not belong in prison and that the appropriate response isn’t to “Māorify” a prison.”

    In sport, FIFA have frozen funding to the Oceania Football Confederation, after ‘irregularities’ were revealed into an audit of an Auckland football facility, reports Stuff. The suspension is temporary, but it also follows the resignation of OFC President David Chung over the audit.

    And in Australia, Israel Folau is really digging in over his comments that homosexual people will go to hell, and is now saying he’s ready to quit the Wallabies, reports the NZ Herald. He’s switched codes a few times before, but if I may make a personal observation, the Australian sporting world has changed a lot in the last few years. I saw first hand the way the AFL instituted anti-discrimination policies, and the NRL has also pushed hard in that area. It could mean there would be no choice for Folau but to go overseas if he walked away from the Wallabies, though that would of course mean a sizeable boost in his income.

    From our partners, Vector’s new technology engineer Kate Murphy writes about the humble LED, and shines a light on the history and impact little things can make on energy reduction at scale.

    That’s it for the The Bulletin. If you liked what you read, and know other people who would find it useful, please forward it on and encourage them to sign up here. If you’ve got feedback or want to send us a message, send us a message at thebulletin@thespinoff.co.nz. Thanks for joining us this morning.

    The Bulletin is brought to you by Vector. If you live in Auckland, they also delivered the power you’re using to read it. And they’re creating a new energy future for all of us, as showcased by the incredible Vector Lights.